Season 4 picks up 18 months after Season 3. Jack works for the Secretary of Defense, James Heller, and is in a serious relationship with his boss' daughter, Audrey. He was fired from CTU due to the drug addiction problem from the previous season. CTU also has a new director, a woman named Erin Driscoll, who took over after Tony was sent to prison for breaking protocol (and the law) to save his wife, Michelle. And we have a new President, Keeler (and eventually Logan) after Palmer refuses to run again for a second term. But when Heller and his daughter are kidnapped, Jack is forced to help out CTU yet again to get them back... which leads into yet another set of master plans to attack the U.S. There's really only one way to describe this season: Lame.
Let's look at the character stories.
Jack Bauer
Jack is too... nice... in this season. I mean, right away he starts off in a great
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/db24c/db24cc53725843b6d8c6271b6f9fdc6f7c5f6c47" alt=""
But most of what Jack does in this season feels like it has no real emotional impact. Kim is completely absent from this season, so she's not kidnapped or in any immediate danger. And after the first few episodes, Audrey isn't in any real danger (not like I cared while she was... but again, I'll get to that). There was just no emotional connection to anything he was doing, so his part of the story was boring. And since he's the center of the show, if Jack's story is boring, the whole thing is boring. There's also a torture theme going on, where he (or CTU) are constantly torturing people and with little to no real care about what they were doing.
James Heller and Audrey Raines
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/759f7/759f7784377de9c062770262c7b600fe660ed166" alt=""
Here was my issue with these two main characters: You're introduced to them, given no real emotional connection except that Audrey and Jack are dating and James is his boss, and they are almost immediately kidnapped. Well... so? While they were kidnapped, I couldn't give a crap about either of them, and they bored from "who cares?" to annoying, particularly Heller. However, Heller did become more likable as the season went on; Audrey, on the other hand, went the opposite direction. Once her husband (who she was separated from) returned, she started heading back to him over Jack, which severed whatever care I had for her (I did like Paul--her husband--though. He was a pretty good character, and I liked the relationship he ended up building with Jack).
And after that, Audrey is just... kind of always around, bouncing between meddling in people's affairs at CTU, getting in the way, and whining about everything. And I honestly just did not care about her one bit.
The Araz Family
This is the second major family of this season. Like the previous family, I
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6fb92/6fb9217bbe40bd2885892320dd5a9ff5e046c638" alt=""
The only major problem I had with this family is that, at one point, Behrooz is traded for Jack by the terrorists... and is never seen again! I mean, what the hell happened to him? According to Wikipedia, there is bonus footage on the DVDs that show him getting rescued by CTU, but I would have liked something to be shown on the actual show. It was just an open-ended plot point, and that annoyed me... especially after playing up his character for the bulk of the season.
Habib Marwan
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a8067/a8067122b2f57b8a6b7b10a9e861b606debade4e" alt=""
Here are all of the mini-acts: We start with the Heller/Audrey kidnapping. Then we have the race to stop nuclear power plants from melting down. Then it starts coming out of nowhere... suddenly there's a guy attempting to steal a stealth jet to shoot down Air Force One. From there, we go to Marwan attempting to steal the nuclear football, which holds all nuclear codes and whatnot for the American arsenal. And then, finally, they steal and launch a nuclear missile. Some of the transitions aren't as fluid as others, but some work (the strangest transition was from nuclear meltdown to stealing of the stealth jet). Overall, it was just like Marwan had a million ideas on how to take down the U.S. and couldn't figure out which one he wanted; meanwhile, they portray it as if it was all one master plan, and it just didn't feel like one. Oh well.
CTU
Here's where I started having some other issues with this season. For the first chunk of the season, there are almost no returning characters, save for Jack and Chloe. But even Chloe leaves the show after the first few episodes, her character getting essentially replaced with a guy named Edgar. But Tony and Michelle are no longer at CTU. There's the new Director of Field Ops. There's the new commander guy at Division. Chase isn't back. Hell, even Kim is gone. Let's look through the characters we do get one at a time.
First we're given Erin Driscoll, the new Director of CTU/Field Ops. And
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/50cf4/50cf4d4426d9723d6224f186b0831a81bf699bdd" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/26e92/26e929750b9f44d636bf47d3830f0dcc1e90aef9" alt=""
And then there's Chloe, who returned from the
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/720fa/720fa5e6fda85b86d19e0e50b3258fd865e2c45b" alt=""
There are a couple other CTU characters introduced, like Marianne, Sarah, and Curtis, but really the only one I cared about was Curtis. Marianne wasn't around very long, and there was just something about Sarah that bugged me. Curtis, on the other hand, was pretty cool, being another regular field agent. But he did have some things about him that bugged me, too (such as his dislike of Tony's eventual return). There was also Bill Buchanan, who took over Chappelle's position, basically. He didn't really evoke feelings from me one way or another. He wasn't an asshole like Chappelle, but he wasn't particularly incompetent at his job like... well... half the people this season. He's just kinda... there.
Finally, there's Tony and Michelle, both of whom come in about halfway through the season (Michelle a little after Tony). It's funny that Tony has essentially become one of my favorite characters, as I couldn't really stand him in Season 1 (then again, I don't think we were supposed to). Sure, he has some personality flaws, but they don't upset me like those of other characters. You can really feel the friendship between him and Jack and the trust that has been built over however many years they've known each other. Michelle, on the other hand, just got on my nerves this season... mostly for how she treated Tony. Yeah, Tony apparently became a drunk bum for a while, but the dude lost his job and went to prison to save her life. And how does she reward him? By leaving him. And on top of that, she treats him like crap when she returns, and then when she's put in a similar situation as he was the previous season? She damn-near acts uppity in the situation... yeah, I really liked her in season 3, especially during the Hotel stuff, but she lost most of my caring this season (which really put a damper on the Season 5 opening).
The Presidents (Keeler/Logan/Palmer)
I never really had strong feelings for President Keeler one way or another, except that I found it strange he was on Air Force One for the majority of the season. At one point he says he'd been flying for 20 hours. Where exactly was he coming from? Did it even say? If it did, I don't think I caught it.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e093b/e093bc270bb083b64618bfffecf3167fa46fce52" alt=""
Eventually, Mike Novick, whose giant head makes a
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d7728/d7728c5869cc3ff9bfb58bff1e3ef8beee25e1c2" alt=""
Overall Thoughts
The season does pick up near the end--but its a too little too late kinda deal. Mandy-The-Hot-Assassin returns yet again, which is part of how the season kind of returns to its old self, as it forces Jack to regain his old personality (since it deals with Tony, as well... somebody he cares about). And there's an almost random Chinese consulate subplot that plays out for the last handful of episodes and leads into Jack's fate and Season 5. And it almost felt tacked on to the main plot like a last minute idea to segue into a plotline for Season 5 (or at least a way to kick off said season). This season had a much different feel from the previous seasons. Ironically, I felt the show held more Republican views of things (such as torture), while the season also gained a Republican President (instead of the Democrat Palmer). There's even a bit of "I'm gay, so you must hate me" in there near the end. But overall, the characters were boring, I only cared about those who were mostly innocent and/or inconsequential (Chloe's friend at the beginning, Behrooz, etc.), and half the cast were annoyingly incompetent at their jobs--with only one really overcoming that obstacle (Edgar). It was an awfully lame season that I probably won't be revisiting... but it is a necessary one, as it sets up Season 5... and from what I've seen so far--one episode--well... damn.
Season 4 is probably my least favourite, but it does have a couple of amazing moments, like when Jack has to pick between the chinese guy and Paul Raines, and when Tony shows up and rescues Jack and Audrey (I totally agree, Tony's my favourite character)
ReplyDeleteAnd Season 5 is probably the best season in my opinion
Tom: I agree. Those are some great moments in Season 4. There are a couple others, too, but the lameness far outweighs the excellence.
ReplyDeleteGeez - you are ploughing your way through these. I have been meaning to comment on these posts for a while.
ReplyDeleteSeason 4 though - Edgar Stiles is a great character. He should have been used more! The young lad in the Araz family looks so much like M. Night Shyamalan that it put me off a little bit - and it didn't help when 'The Mummy' turned up.
The decision Tom Clift mentions is interesting but, lets face it, Paul Raines was so boring...
I though Season 4 was weak - but Season 5 ... woah. I think the first coupl of episodes are better than the entire Season 4.
Simon
www.screeninsight.com